Thursday, May 9, 2013

"The Task Before Us"

For the past couple years the world of higher education has been grappling with the latest innovation that promises to transform the classroom: the Massive Open Online Course, or MOOC. If a movement could be undone by the phonetic quality of its own acronym, MOOCs would die a swift death. Just saying the word out loud brings to mind some kind of ill-conceived alien character from the Star Wars universe that was best left on the cutting room floor... like Mooc, Chewbacca's lovable half-wit wookie buddy.

Instead the word is starting to make regular appearances in the rotation of newspaper columns, as public intellectuals take turns predicting the overturning of the old university order. At the New York Times Tom Friedman has described the explosion of online courses as a revolution. Twice. He confirmed this assessment in a column in March, noting that a revolution must be underway because his buddy from Harvard, professor Michael Sandel, has so many fans of his online course in Korea that some of them gave him new sneakers. Proof positive for Friedman. Coursera, EdX, Udacity... these are the Oxfords and Cambridges of the future. Friedman related this vision of the future he gleaned from talking with Rafael Reif, president of MIT:
Many universities will offer online courses to students anywhere in the world, in which they will earn “credentials” — certificates that testify that they have done the work and passed all the exams. The process of developing credible credentials that verify that the student has adequately mastered the subject — and did not cheat — and can be counted on by employers is still being perfected by all the MOOCs. But once it is, this phenomenon will really scale.
"Scale" is an ugly word when it comes to education. Maybe not "MOOC" ugly, but ugly enough. Anytime the language of corporatism is applied to academia, misapprehension is certain to follow. Sure enough, just when you really need David Brooks to come through with a topically nonsensical column, he does just that. Let it be said that Brooks always strikes, and misses, when the iron is hot. Borrowing (and drastically oversimplifying) a distinction from 20th century conservative philosopher Michael Oakeshott, Brooks says that online education will force traditional universities away from teaching technical knowledge and towards emphasizing practical knowledge. Technical knowledge, says Brooks, "is like the recipes in a cookbook. It is formulas telling you roughly what is to be done." This is the stuff that the internet can teach. He likens practical knowledge to the skills described in Sheryl Sandberg's book Lean In:
...the ability to be assertive in a meeting; to disagree pleasantly; to know when to interrupt and when not to; to understand the flow of discussion and how to change people’s minds; to attract mentors; to understand situations; to discern what can change and what can’t.
Represented here is the problem, a deeply limited conception of higher education's purpose as the imparting of modern trade skills. College as corporate pre-season. Education in this paradigm is about information transmission and board-room etiquette. On this spectrum, traditional thinkers will end up on Wall St. while creative thinkers will end up in Silicon Valley, but everyone's doing big business.

It has taken some time, but resistance to the MOOC phenomenon is finally starting to take shape. Few people in education with experience and wisdom are decrying the internet as another important tool for pedagogues. Even skeptics understand the allure of democratizing education. But the manner in which Friedman and Brooks talk about education and the MOOC "revolution" is ridiculous, as readers have pointed out. Responses to Friedman noted the incredibly poor completion rates and the illusion of access for the poor when, in fact, mostly members of the upper-middle class take advantage of online courses (until they drop out). This is a particularly worthwhile criticism since, as Ross Douthat recently pointed out, maintaining class divisions is what elite colleges and universities do best despite their egalitarian aspirations. Meanwhile professors from different colleges and universities criticized Brooks for his narrow interpretation of higher education. Loren Byrne at Roger Williams University wrote:
Thus, an essential, if not primary, answer to Mr. Brooks’s question, “What is a university for?,” should be promoting knowledge and understanding for their own sake — beyond any relevance to a job — and educating thoughtful, caring citizens who have the skills and motivation for helping advance the well-being and flourishing of individuals and communities.
And, as sharp as he is concise, William Pritchard of Amherst College responded:
David Brooks suggests that universities are places where students acquire two kinds of knowledge, “technical” and “practical.” I see little difference between these kinds, but I see a large difference between them and “liberal knowledge.”

What used to be called a liberal education was one that aspired, through the study of literature, philosophy, history and science, to intellectual excellence. For many students and some teachers, such liberal knowledge appears not to count for much.
Yes... and for some pundits too. Pritchard, I would imagine, was one of the 70 faculty at Amherst that just voted against the school joining EdX. (Full disclosure: as an alumnus of Amherst, I am proud of them for doing so.) As The Chronicle of Higher Education observed, the vote was not close (70-36, with 5 abstentions). Other universities have followed suit.

I have no idea what will happen with MOOCs, but I doubt very much a revolution is in the works. Which is not to say a revolution might not be welcome, but if that is the case I suggest that instead of looking online, we reaffirm what John Dewey wrote in his 1939 essay "Creative Democracy—The Task Before Us":
For what is the faith of democracy in the role of consultation, of conference, of  persuasion, of discussion, in formation of public opinion, which in the long run is self-corrective, except faith in the capacity of the intelligence of the common man to respond with commonsense to the free play of facts and ideas which are secured by effective guarantees of free inquiry, free assembly and free communication?
Really, I don't know how you teach that in an online course.


  1. Aw, this was a very nice post. In concept I would like to put in writing like this additionally – taking time and precise effort to make a very good article… but what can I say… I procrastinate alot and by no means seem to get one thing done. Hadoop Online Training .

  2. There are lots of information about latest technology and how to get trained in them, like Best Hadoop Training in Chennai have spread around the web, but this is a unique one according to me. The strategy you have updated here will make me to get trained in future technologies(Best hadoop training institute in chennai). By the way you are running a great blog. Thanks for sharing this.

    Big Data Course in Chennai | Big Data Training Chennai

  3. Thank you for sharing like this information. This is the most easy way of learning. This helps me to get some idea regarding this and helps me to bring a creative thought.
    Hadoop Training in Chennai

  4. Excellent post!!! Java is most popular and efficient programming language available in the market today. It helps developers to create stunning desktop/web applications loaded with stunning functionalities. Java Course in Chennai | Best JAVA Training in Chennai


  5. Hadoop online training in hyderabad.All the basic and get the full knowledge of hadoop.
    hadoop online training in hyderbad

  6. nice article on the task before us the mooc is good platform for learning online courses you kept such a nice posts for best online hadoop training online hadoop training.
    hadoop is the best framework in programing languages learn and get the full knowledge of hadoop.

  7. hadoop online training is the best online training course in hyderabad

  8. Thank you for this valuable information. I have got some important suggestions from it. Get your business to the next level in simple steps.
    erp software company in chennai | erp software providers in chennai.

  9. Nice blog. Thank you for sharing. The information you shared is very effective for learners I have got some important suggestions from it. erp software in chennai.

  10. Excellent post. Keep updating.I have got some useful information form this article.
    cloud erp in chennai | erp software solutions provider in chennai

  11. This blog is so nice to me. I will continue to come here again and again. Visit my link as well. Good luck..Web Designing Training Institute in Chennai | Web Designing Training in Velachery

  12. Pretty article! I found some useful information in your blog, it was awesome to read, thanks for sharing this great content to my vision, keep sharing.
    Software Testing Training Center in Chennai | | Best Selenium Training Institute in Chennai | Six Sigma Certification Training in Chennai

  13. I hope this will help many readers who are in need of this vital piece of information. Thanks for sharing & keep your blog updated.
    No.1 Software Testing Training Institute in Chennai | Best Selenium Training Institute in Chennai | ISTQB Certification Center in Velachery

  14. I really enjoyed the post..Thanks for sharing such a nice post..Keep update your post..
    C &C++ Training in Chennai | Embedded System Training in Chennai | VLSI Training Center in Chennai

  15. I found a lot of interesting information here. A really good post
    office 2010 professional plus key deutsch